Journalists and academics bear the brunt of the massive crackdown on freedom of expression in Turkey. Scores of them are currently subject to criminal investigations or behind bars. This website is dedicated to tracking the legal process against them.


The prosecutor objected to the acquittal of Karabay, who stayed in pre-trial detention for 11 days as part of the case. The case will be taken to appellate court
CANSU PİŞKİN, İSTANBUL
Third hearing in the trial of journalist Furkan Karabay who is charged with “marking those involved with the fight against terrorism” and “insulting a public official" over a news article titled “Mafya davasında rüşvet kavgası tutanaklarda: Polis nereye bıraktıysa oradan aldı, konuşursam çarşı pazar karışır” (Bribery fight in Mafia case is in the minutes: Police took it from wherever they left it, if I talk about it, the bazaar will be confused) published on Gerçek Gündem news site, and a social media post, was held at the İstanbul 24th High Criminal Court on 1 October 2024.
Furkan Karabay and his lawyer were present at the hearing, which P24 monitored.
The prosecutor repeated their final opinion on the case presented in the previous hearing, and demanded that Karabay be sentenced for the impugned crimes.
Making his defense against the final opinion, Karabay said, “I stand behind every word I wrote. If the same allegations were in question today, I would write it again. Because this is my duty. I serve as a public official. I do not regret the news I reported. I am also sure of the accuracy of my reporting. I do not recognize any sentence or acquittal decision you will issue” The presiding judge responded “It was brave” to Karabay, who completed his defense.
Karabay's lawyer Enes Hikmet Ermaner said, “As a journalist, my client reported the minutes of the trial of Barış Saral, the leader of a mafia organization. The İstanbul Chief Public Prosecutor's Office does not dare to file a lawsuit against Barış Saral, the owner of the allegations, so it is filing a lawsuit against my client.” Ermaner said that the elements of the crime did not form in terms of both charges, and asked for Karabay's acquittal.
Asked for his last word, Karabay said, “I do not recognize you and I do not demand acquittal.” The presiding judge said, “The disrespect you show may cause you trouble elsewhere. It can happen here too, just so you know,” and recessed the hearing for the verdict.
The court acquitted Karabay unanimously on the charge of “marking those involved with the fight against terrorism” and by majority vote on the charge of “insulting a public official.”
On the other hand, the prosecutor objected to the acquittal verdict “due to its inclusion of matters contrary to the procedure and the law.” In their petition to İstanbul 24th High Criminal Court, the prosecutor requested the notification of the reasoned verdict to the prosecutor's office in order to file an appeal.
Background of the case
Karabay was sent to pre-trial detention on 29 December 2023 on the charge of “marking the officials assigned with the fight against terrorism as targets” by the İstanbul 7th Criminal Court of Peace. The reason for the charge and imprisonment was the news item titled “Mafya davasında rüşvet kavgası tutanaklarda: Polis nereye bıraktıysa oradan aldı, konuşursam çarşı pazar karışır,” (Minutes show bribery fight in mafia case: Police picked it up right where they dropped it off; What I could tell would cause an uproar) which was published on the Gerçek Gündem news site on 27 December 2023 and Karabay’s post on X platform on the same date which read, “Murat Bircan, member of the 13th High Criminal Court which has violated the Constitution, was once an AKP candidate for MP for Samsun.” Upon the objection to his imprisonment, Karabay was released on 8 January 2024 under an obligation to sign his name once a week at the police station and a ban on travelling abroad.
The indictment filed by the İstanbul Chief Prosecutor’s Office on 18 January 2024 cited the news item and the social media post above as evidence of the charge. The indictment reads as follows: “Given that naming Şaban Yılmaz, who is serving as the chief prosecutor at the İstanbul Courthouse, which has carried out many operations against PKK/KCK and FETÖ/PDY armed terrorist organization and many criminal organizations and which has put up a determined struggle against such organizations; Okan Albayrak, who has served as the President of the İstanbul Commission of Justice; and judge Murat Bircan, member of the 13th High Criminal Court which is charged with prosecuting terrorism charges with such imputations and perception forming can clearly serve no purpose other than to mark these individuals as targets to these organizations; therefore the suspect has committed the crime of marking people serving in counter-terrorism as targets; furthermore that the suspect has included the petition by İstanbul Anadolu Chief Prosecutor İsmail Uçar in the news items to make tangible imputations to create the perception that bribes were being received and that this aspect of the suspects’ actions renders them of a nature damaging to honor and dignity and therefore results in the crime of publicly insulting a public official due to their duties; it is concluded that the suspect has committed the crimes of marking people serving in counter-terrorism as targets and publicly insulting a public official due to their duties…”
At the request of Karabay's lawyer Enes Hikmet Ermaner, an expert opinion filed by Punto24 Independent Journalism Association (P24) with lawyer Benan Molu, registered at Istanbul Bar Association No. 1, was submitted to the court on 2 July 2024.
The expert opinion emphasized that an imprisonment sentence may violate the freedom of expression and press guaranteed by the Constitution and the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), and the prohibition of restricting these rights and freedoms for political reasons.
