Expression Interrupted

Journalists and academics bear the brunt of the massive crackdown on freedom of expression in Turkey. Scores of them are currently subject to criminal investigations or behind bars. This website is dedicated to tracking the legal process against them.

ANALYSIS | Local journalists face "disinformation" pressure: Second detention and imprisonment over same news story

ANALYSIS | Local journalists face

İrem Delice, a reporter for the Aydın Denge newspaper, was detained twice and subsequently jailed over the same news story on charges of “spreading false information.” Delice became the second journalist to face this situation, following Sebahattin Yum, another journalist working locally. The journalists commented that “local journalists are more easily targeted”

ALİ SAFA KORKUT

On 25 August, Aydın Denge daily shared the news of the death of a citizen named Gülşen Erdoğan on its Facebook page under the headline "Erdoğan has died." Following reports alleging that the headline “gave the impression that President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan had died,” an investigation was launched against the newspaper’s staff.

Under the charge of “spreading false information,” the newspaper’s Chief Editorial Coordinator Emin Aydın, Editor-in-Chief Yeşim Ülker, and reporters İslam Keleş and İrem Delice were detained on 25 August.

Of these journalists, Keleş was released after completing police procedures, whilst the other three were released on the same day under judicial supervision by the duty criminal judgeship of peace.

However, the Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office appealed against the release of Delice, and the journalist was re-detained on 28 August under the same charge and imprisoned pending trial.

Speaking to “Expression Interrupted,” Emin Aydın, General Publication Coordinator of the Aydın Denge newspaper, denied the claim that the post was intended to refer to President Erdoğan.

Stating that this was not the first time they had used this headline, Aydın said, “We have used the same headline at least 20 more times in the past. We have previously used the headline ‘Imamoğlu has died,’ as well as ‘Mehmet Şimşek has died.’ It is a template. We only use the surname when the full name of the deceased is long. This is just one such example. There is absolutely nothing that would justify Delice’s second detention, let alone her imprisonment in the first place.”

Although Delice was detained twice under the same news story on charges of “spreading false information,” she is not the first journalist to have experienced this.

On 14 October 2025, İhlas News Agency (İHA) reporter Sebahattin Yum was detained twice within a few hours of each other on same charges, following a report titled “The governor has an umbrella, but veterans do not.”

“You are an easier target as local journalist”

Commenting on the experiences of Delice and himself, Yum said, “The fact that a journalist can be detained twice solely upon the orders of a local governor or police chief, is one of the clearest indicators of the state of press freedom.”

Speaking about the fact that both journalists subjected to this situation work locally, Yum remarked, “The stories you report can upset certain people more quickly at a local level. You become an easier target here and feel the pressure more keenly. That is what happened to me too, and I was detained upon orders.”

“Detention is being used as a tool of punishment rather than a precautionary measure”

The cases of Delice and Yum are examples illustrating that the charge of “spreading false information” may not be limited to an investigation and initial detention for journalists.

According to Delice’s lawyer, Ayşe Nur Altıncı Toprak, the legal basis for this practice is also contentious.

Toprak, who stated that her client’s second detention and subsequent imprisonment were carried out not on the basis of new evidence but on the basis of an order, said the following: “However, for this to happen, new evidence relating to the case must emerge, or the suspect must have engaged in a behavior that raises the suspicion of absconding, or there must be a risk of evidence being tampered with. In our case, however, none of these apply.”

Noting that detention should normally be a judicial supervision measure, Toprak remarked, “Nowadays, however, it is being used as a punitive tool rather than a precautionary measure. This is evident in the Delice case as well.”

Öğret: “Local journalists are more vulnerable to pressure”

Özgür Öğret, the Turkey Representative of the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ), said, “In both cases, the peculiarity lies not in the journalists being detained once or twice, but in the fact that their reports have become the subject of an investigation.”

Noting that local media organizations and journalists working locally are more vulnerable to pressure, Öğret said, “There is no difference between national and local media when it comes to impunity, but it is fair to say that local media workers remain at a disadvantage. In particular, since the disinformation law came into force, there has been an increase in cases across the country where local media workers have been subjected to investigations, taken into custody and sent to prison.”

Noting that journalism is viewed with hostility, Öğret said that the charge of “spreading false information” is one of the greatest obstacles to press freedom

Top