Expression Interrupted

Journalists and academics bear the brunt of the massive crackdown on freedom of expression in Turkey. Scores of them are currently subject to criminal investigations or behind bars. This website is dedicated to tracking the legal process against them.

Court rules for acquittal and release of İsmail Arı

Court rules for acquittal and release of İsmail Arı

Journalist İsmail Arı, who had been in custody for 30 days following a complaint by former RTÜK Chairman Ebubekir Şahin, has been acquitted of both charges at end of the first hearing

BÜŞRA TAŞKIRAN, ANKARA

The first hearing in the case brought against BirGün reporter İsmail Arı on charges of “disseminating misleading information” and “insult,” following a complaint by former Radio and Television Supreme Council (RTÜK) Chairman Ebubekir Şahin, was held at the Ankara 32nd Criminal Court of First Instance on 19 November 2026.

At the hearing, which was monitored by P24, the jailed journalist Arı and his lawyers were present. Among those observing the trial were Elçin Özge Şimşek Çağlayan, President of the Ankara Bar Association; Utku Çakırözer and Mahmut Tanal, MPs from the New Party; representatives of the Contemporary Journalists’ Association; members of the BirGün School Initiative; and numerous journalists.

After his identity was verified, İsmail Arı presented his defense and raised objections regarding the process leading to his arrest. Arı stated that the court had not listened to his statements nor recorded them in the minutes; he noted that he had gone to the police station of his own accord, yet had been imprisoned on the grounds of a suspected risk of absconding.

Arı noted that he had attended whenever the prosecutor who drafted the indictment had summoned him for questioning, and argued that his arrest was unconstitutional, despite the fact that freedom of the press is guaranteed under the Constitution. Arı explained that the social media post at the center of the case was related to his reposting of a post made by Ebubekir Şahin on social media, stating, “I was arrested for reposting Ebubekir Şahin’s tweet in a manner unprecedented anywhere in the world.”

Recalling Şahin’s post regarding his attendance at an event with Osman Nacar—whose name had come up in a funding investigation—Arı said he had shared this information alongside a report from the Cumhuriyet newspaper. Arı emphasized that the source of the report was Şahin’s own social media post.

Arı noted that the indictment claimed a journalist must verify the reliability of their source, adding, “The source is Ebubekir Şahin, and the prosecution is labelling my source as unreliable.”

Arı pointed out that the indictment assessed his own post as “distorting the apparent truth,” stating, “It is the prosecution that is distorting the apparent truth. My source is Ebubekir Şahin.”

Arı said that the indictment alleged an attempt to link Şahin to the funding investigation, but that he himself had made no such claim. He explained that in his post, he had merely relayed publicly available information regarding the relationship between Nacar—whose name was mentioned in the investigation—and Şahin. Arı, who argued that the indictment was internally contradictory, said that Şahin’s post was initially cited as a source, but was later characterized as containing false information at the end of the indictment.

Arı also reacted to the fact that one of the grounds for the charges against him was that “his post had caused fear, anxiety and public outrage,” asking: “I shared Şahin’s tweet and caused economic unrest. Are people unable to make ends meet because of me? Is diesel TL 100 because of me? Is one dollar TL 50 because of me?”

Emphasizing that he had been in custody for 30 days, Arı, at the end of his defene, drew attention to the statement in the indictment regarding “the defendant’s honour, dignity and reputation having been violated,” saying, “I would like to thank the prosecution for this statement.”

Kerem Altıparmak: “This provision is being applied against journalists”

Kerem Altıparmak, one of Arı’s lawyers, raised objections in his defense regarding the unconstitutionality of the charge of “spreading misleading information” (Article 217/A of the Turkish Penal Code.)

Noting that the provision in question was introduced to combat disinformation but, in practice, has led to journalists being prosecuted for their press activities, Altıparmak argued that, despite a previous ruling by the Constitutional Court, the article is being applied in a different manner with regard to journalistic activities.

Altıparmak said, “This article is applied exclusively to journalists. To safeguard press freedom in Turkey, this provision must be annulled.” He requested that the court apply to the Constitutional Court for the annulment of the ruling.

Altıparmak argued that the indictment treated the complainant’s personal grievance as if it were a general grievance affecting the whole of Turkey, and stated that Arı’s post was not of a nature to disrupt public order. Altıparmak argued that the case had been brought for political reasons, drawing attention to the European Court of Human Rights’ rulings regarding the press’s role as a watchdog of the public. Noting that news reports based on the statements of others are an important part of journalistic activity, Altıparmak said that journalists’ harsh criticism of public officials should be considered within the scope of freedom of expression.

Ankara Bar Association President Çağlayan: “Detention has become a method of punishment”

Elçin Özge Şimşek Çağlayan, President of the Ankara Bar Association, also highlighted the relationship between press freedom and freedom of expression in her defence. Stating that whilst press freedom is linked to freedom of expression, it constitutes a separate right, Çağlayan said they had previously argued that Article 217/A of the Turkish Penal Code could not be applied to journalists.

Stating that for a crime to have been committed, there must be concrete evidence that the allegations are contrary to the truth, Çağlayan argued that there was no such evidence in Arı’s post.

Reminding the court that detention is a precautionary measure, Çağlayan stated, “Detention is a precautionary measure. At this stage, however, detention has turned into a method of punishment,” and called for Arı’s release.

“The post is not likely to disrupt public order”

Taylan Arı, one of Arı’s lawyers, stated that his client was a journalist and that in his social media posts he conveyed news, assessments of current affairs and criticism.

Stating that the post in question should be assessed within the scope of journalistic activity, Taylan Arı noted that the offense under Article 217/A of the Turkish Penal Code could be committed with specific intent, whilst his client had acted with journalistic intent. Arı argued that the post was not capable of disturbing public order and stated that the offense of insult had not been committed in this specific case.

Lawyer Tolgay Güvercin, meanwhile, questioned how the reposting Şahin’s social media post could create panic amongst the public. Noting that a concrete danger must arise for the offense to be established, Güvercin pointed out that the indictment did not explain which statement constituted an offense or on what grounds.

Güvercin stated that the decision on which his client’s detention was based did not contain sufficient grounds, that the charges in the case file had not been substantiated in concrete terms, and requested his client’s release.

Berfin Şaşman, the lawyer for the complainant Ebubekir Şahin, stated that the complaints remained valid. Şaşman said that Arı had admitted to making the social media posts himself, and argued that the posts targeted her client and created a misleading perception regarding a person holding public office.

Şaşman requested that Arı remain in custody and be sentenced upon the conclusion of the trial.

The prosecutor, presenting their final opinion on the case, assessed that the offense could not be formed by perception alone and could not be committed in this manner; consequently, he requested that Arı be acquitted of the charges brought against him on the grounds that the elements of the alleged offense were not present.

The court ruled that the elements of the offense had not been established and acquitted İsmail Arı of the charges of “publicly disseminating misleading information” and “insult.” Arı was also ordered to be released.

Following the ruling, İsmail Arı, who left the courtroom accompanied by gendarmes, said, “There are still judges in Ankara.”

Background of the case

Arı, a reporter for the BirGün newspaper, had been summoned on 20 October 2026 to the Security Branch of the Ankara Police Headquarters to give a statement. Arı, who went to the police station to give his statement, was taken into custody there.

After spending one day in custody, Arı was transferred to Ankara Courthouse, where on 21 October he was imprisoned pending trial on charges of “insulting a public official” and “disseminating misleading information,” and sent to prison.

The indictment stated that in a post dated 8 October 2026, Arı had quoted a post concerning Osman Arıkan Nacar, whose name had been mentioned in the Cumhuriyet newspaper’s report on funding investigation, and had brought to light a post relating to the opening of a school conference hall attended by Ebubekir Şahin in 2023.

It was alleged that the post in question sought to create the impression that the complainant was linked to the funding investigation by highlighting the fact that both Şahin and Nacar were present at the same opening and that the complainant had referred to Nacar in his post.

The indictment included the allegation that the post was intended to damage the complainant’s reputation and had led to the formation of a false impression about him in the public eye.

Top