Expression Interrupted

Journalists and academics bear the brunt of the massive crackdown on freedom of expression in Turkey. Scores of them are currently subject to criminal investigations or behind bars. This website is dedicated to tracking the legal process against them.

Case filed against Gözde Şeker and İbrahim Kahveci upon complaint by Devlet Bahçeli begins

Case filed against Gözde Şeker and İbrahim Kahveci upon complaint by Devlet Bahçeli begins

MHP Chairman Devlet Bahçeli had lodged a complaint against Şeker and Kahveci, citing their reporting on the murder of Sinan Ateş. The indictment was accepted after being returned four times

CANAN COŞKUN, ISTANBUL

Following a complaint by MHP Chairman Devlet Bahçeli, a case was brought against journalists Gözde Şeker and İbrahim Kahveci at the Ankara 52nd Criminal Court of First Instance on charges of “insult by means of an oral, written or visual communication” and “defamation” over their remarks about the Sinan Ateş murder. The preliminary hearing for this case was held at the Anadolu 38th Criminal Court of First Instance on 16 September 2026.

At the hearing, which was covered by P24, Gözde Şeker and her lawyer Kazım Yiğit Akalın were present, whilst journalist İbrahim Kahveci did not attend as the date specified in the summons for his statement to be taken was different.

After her identity was verified, Şeker presented her defense, stating: “I have been working as a journalist since I was 16. For the past 10 years, I have spent hours on end practicing journalism. This is the first time in my professional career that I have faced such an allegation. I have never made any insults or false accusations. My words fall within the scope of journalism and criticism. Where appropriate, I have also criticized figures from the opposition. In some of my comments, I have been accused by viewers of being a supporter of Bahçeli. This, too, is evidence of my objectivity. I had no intention of insulting or slandering Bahçeli.”

Following Şeker’s statement, the court moved on to the statements of her lawyer, Kazım Yiğit Akalın. Akalın stated: “In the broadcast in question, my client was the moderator. The prosecutor has quoted the statements referred to in the indictment in quotation marks, but what is claimed to be a sentence spoken by Gözde Şeker was actually posed as a question. Furthermore, the indictment has in fact been returned four times. The reason for the final return was that it did not specify which statement corresponded to which offense. This situation remains unclear in the indictment. As the elements of the offense are not present and the remarks fall within the scope of criticism, I request my client’s acquittal.”

The court adjourned the case until 20 October 2026 to take the statement of the other defendant, Kahveci.

Background of the case

Devlet Bahçeli, through his lawyer, alleged on 12 June 2024 that during the “Kırmızı Çizgi” (Red Line) program hosted by Gözde Şeker on Halk TV at the time, İbrahim Kahveci had made statements alongside her that constituted “defamation,” “insult” and “incitement of the public to hatred and rebellion” against him and his party.

In the complaint filed by Bahçeli’s lawyer, it was noted that the program featured footage of President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s meeting with New Party leader Özgür Özel, who was the CHP leader at the time, and Ayşe Ateş, the widow of the murdered former Grey Wolves chairman Sinan Ateş, as well as footage of Bahçeli’s group meeting in the Grand National Assembly of Turkey.

In the indictment dated 14 October 2024 filed by the Ankara Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office, although the broadcast took place at Halk TV’s Istanbul studio, the place of the impugned crime was listed as Ankara. The statements made by Şeker and Bahçeli during the broadcast were also included. Kahveci had stated that Ayşe Ateş, wife of Sinan Ateş, had requested that the investigation be extended to her husband’s killers and those who aided them, and that Bahçeli had made statements in anticipation of the possibility of such an investigation. Later in his speech, Kahveci made the grey wolf sign with his hand and recounted how Selçuk Özdağ, then Deputy Chair of the Future Party, and journalists had narrowly escaped death following an attack by “nationalist-looking individuals.” Şeker also stated that Bahçeli’s rhetoric regarding Kurdish politics was aimed at dividing the country, adding that they had been marginalized from politics as a result of this stance. Kahveci also noted that the failure to shed light on the murder of Sinan Ateş and the protection afforded to the perpetrators had sent the message that “they could go and shoot whoever they wanted.” It was reported that Gözde Şeker had said, “Even if I were to read this statement anonymously, I would say that Devlet Bahçeli said it. In other words, it is yet another statement made in that harsh, poisonous language.”

During her interrogation at the prosecutor’s office on 14 August 2024, Şeker stated that she had been working as a journalist for 20 years, adding, “Throughout my professional life, I have never deviated from the principles of journalism. The comment in question falls within these principles. My statement in question certainly does not contain any insult.” Şeker stated that she rejected the charges pressed against her. Kahveci also stated during his questioning on 17 September 2024 that he had expressed his views and opinions as part of his professional activities, within the scope of freedom of thought and expression guaranteed by the Constitution. He explained that the remarks in question related to a political murder case, emphasizing that he had not targeted any specific individual and that his remarks did not contain any allegations that would undermine, discredit or humiliate a person’s honor, dignity or reputation.

The journalists’ remarks in the broadcast in question related to Bahçeli’s speech at the group meeting on 11 June 2024. In that speech, Bahçeli had said: “Our president, of course, can meet with anyone, speak to anyone and listen to anyone; in our view, there is no harm or objection to this. What we consider objectionable is the spread of baseless rumors, the escalation of absurd allegations, and the fueling of discord.” Bahçeli continued his remarks regarding the murder of Sinan Ateş in a press statement the following day, saying, “The spread of a smear campaign against the Nationalist-Ideological Movement through a murder case for which an indictment has been filed, the constant promotion of certain individuals associated with this smear campaign, and furthermore, their being paraded from door to door and shown on screen after screen, constitutes a full-scale attempt to poison the atmosphere of internal peace and harmony, going beyond any quest for justice and the rule of law.”

The prosecution, noting that Bahçeli was performing a public duty, argued that the journalists’ actions were of a nature to undermine Bahçeli’s honor, dignity and reputation. It alleged that they had “publicly insulted and defamed him by attributing a specific act contrary to the law to him.” The prosecutor who drafted the indictment was R.H., who would later draft the indictment for the criminal case concerning allegations of irregularities at the CHP’s 38th Ordinary Congress.

The indictment drawn up against Gözde Şeker and İbrahim Kahveci was returned four times. The indictment was first examined by the Ankara 2nd Criminal Court of First Instance. The court returned the indictment, stating that the case did not relate to a press offense and should be heard under general provisions.

The prosecution subsequently forwarded the case to the Ankara 52nd Criminal Court of First Instance. This court also returned the indictment, noting that no report had been obtained from the Radio and Television Supreme Council (RTÜK), that the statements made by Gözde Şeker and İbrahim Kahveci had not been distinguished from one another, and that it was not specified which statement corresponded to which charge.

The indictment was then revised and sent to another criminal court of first instance in Ankara. However, this court also returned the indictment, stating that the case file should be sent back to the previous court.

When the case file reached the Ankara 52nd Criminal Court of First Instance once more, it was noted that the RTÜK report had now been obtained. However, the court returned the indictment once more, noting that it had still not been clarified which statements constituted “defamation” and which constituted “insult.”

Approximately one year after this series of returns, the indictment was sent back to the Ankara 52nd Criminal Court of First Instance without any changes having been made. This time, the court accepted the indictment in March 2026. The court in Ankara issued a written instruction to the Anadolu 38th Criminal Court in Istanbul to take Şeker’s statement. A written instruction was also issued to the same court to take Kahveci’s statement; however, the court set Kahveci’s hearing date for 14 October

Top