Expression Interrupted

Journalists and academics bear the brunt of the massive crackdown on freedom of expression in Turkey. Scores of them are currently subject to criminal investigations or behind bars. This website is dedicated to tracking the legal process against them.

Canan Coşkun and Kazım Kızıl who were investigating Rabia Naz’s death appears in court

Canan Coşkun and Kazım Kızıl who were investigating Rabia Naz’s death appears in court

In the case brought seven years later against two journalists investigating Rabia Naz’s death and her father, Şaban Vatan, the plaintiff, Küçükal, has given contradictory statements. The court has decided to hear the witnesses

The first hearing in the case brought against journalist Canan Coşkun, documentary-maker Kazım Kızıl and Rabia Naz Vatan’s father, Şaban Vatan, who were investigating the death of Rabia Naz Vatan in the Eynesil district of Giresun, was held at the Görele 1st Criminal Court of First Instance on 22 October 2026.

Canan Coşkun joined the hearing at the Görele 1st Criminal Court via the judicial videoconferencing system (SEGBİS) from Istanbul, whilst Kazım Kızıl joined from İzmir. Şaban Vatan was present in person at the Görele Courthouse.

Coşkun, Kızıl and Vatan are charged with “depriving a person of their liberty by means of force, threats or deception, committed jointly by more than one person.” Kızıl also faces a charge of “attempting to influence a fair trial.”

The hearing began with the defense statement by journalist Canan Coşkun. Coşkun stated that, like many other journalists, she had traveled to Eynesil in November 2019 to investigate the incident, and that she had spoken to Küçükal because he was the last person to have seen Rabia Naz whilst she was injured. She added that, at that time, the Parliamentary Inquiry Commission was also investigating the incident in Giresun and that she had provided information on the matter to commission member Jale Nur Süllü.

He explained that during the interview, after Şaban Vatan joined them, Küçükal suddenly threw himself to the ground and began re-enacting the moment he last saw Rabia Naz, dragging himself along the ground and injuring himself in the process. He said they were deeply disturbed by the situation and objected, but were unable to stop him; consequently, he and Kazım Kızıl left the scene.

Coşkun emphasized that it was clear from the transcripts of the audio recordings taken throughout the meeting that Küçükal’s claims did not reflect the truth, and he requested that these audio recordings be played in court.

Kızıl: “At the time of the incident in question, we were acting purely as observers

Documentary-maker Kazım Kızıl explained that he and several journalists, including Canan Coşkun, were producing a documentary about Rabia Naz’s death. 

Kızıl reported that Küçükal began crawling on the floor even though no one had asked him to do so, adding, “On one side was a key witness who had changed his statement, and on the other was Rabia Naz’s father. There was one person there trying to prove his claim, and two people who did not believe that claim to be true. Whilst all this was happening, Canan Coşkun and I were standing side by side, and we were purely in an observer capacity.” 

Both journalists denied the charges and requested acquittal.

Vatan: “Why am I on trial?”

Rabia Naz’s father, Şaban Vatan, said that as a father trying to shed light on his daughter’s death, he had asked Küçükal some questions. He stated that he had filmed the events of the day in question to gather evidence and submitted the footage to the court.

Vatan went on as follows: “My daughter is dead. Is it a crime to ask questions of this man who has repeatedly lied about my daughter’s condition? Why am I on trial? Is not changing one’s statement a crime? Is not deceiving the court a crime, Your Honour?”

Küçükal gave contradictory statements

Mürsel Küçükal, the plaintiff on whom the case is based, said he had nothing further to add and that the statements he had given to the police were valid. Following the judge’s warning, Küçükal began to describe the moment of the incident, saying, “Mrs. Canan told me she was a Member of Parliament. She said that Şaban was a dangerous man and could harm me. Then she asked me to show her the scene of the incident.”

Küçükal, who had stated at the start of his testimony that he had begun crawling on the ground of his own accord, said in response to the judge’s question that the incident of crawling on the ground had taken place at the request of journalists. He said he could not recall certain details whilst the judge was asking questions. In these sections, the judge read out Küçükal’s statement to the police.

Lawyer Yalçın: “We are requesting that Küçükal be referred to the Forensic Medicine Institute for a mental health assessment”

Abbas Yalçın, Coşkun’s lawyer, pointed out that Mürsel Küçükal had given inconsistent answers to questions even during this hearing. Yalçın stated that the audio recordings of the incident were available and that Küçükal had lied in court. He requested that Küçükal be referred to the Institute of Forensic Medicine for an assessment of his mental health. 

He also requested that all video recordings from the day of the incident be examined by a new panel of experts. Furthermore, he requested that the other individuals, against whom a decision of “no grounds for prosecution” had been issued during the investigation, be heard as witnesses in court.

The court accepted the request to hear witnesses and adjourned the case until 28 January 2027. 

Background of the case 

Rabia Naz, aged 11, was found injured outside her home in the Eynesil district of Giresun on 12 April 2018 and later died in hospital.

In November 2019, journalists Coşkun, Kızıl and Rabia Naz’s father, Şaban Vatan, traveled to Eynesil to investigate her death. Seven years later, a case was brought against them on charges of “depriving a person of their liberty by using force or threats in concert with one or more other persons,” relating to an interview they conducted with a witness at the scene of the incident. Kızıl was also charged with “attempting to influence a fair trial.” 

In 2020, the public prosecutor’s office issued a decision to drop the case, stating that “Rabia Naz Vatan had died after falling from the roof of her home.”

In September 2025, the Constitutional Court ruled that the right to life had been violated on the grounds that the investigation had been “conducted negligently.”

Top