Journalists and academics bear the brunt of the massive crackdown on freedom of expression in Turkey. Scores of them are currently subject to criminal investigations or behind bars. This website is dedicated to tracking the legal process against them.


Censorship of the press did not begin with T24. The ongoing silence in the face of other publishers being blocked has widened the scope of censorship. Yet the solutions being sought today still fail to grasp the true scale of the problem
ALİ SAFA KORKUT
In her book Science: A Four-Thousand-Year History, the British writer Patricia Fara states: “The issue is not that they cannot see the solution, but that they cannot see the problem.”
When I first read this, I did not anticipate that I would come to use it so frequently. Yet, as someone living in Turkey, I ought to have foreseen this. Admittedly, the issue may not simply be that I failed to foresee this. Perhaps, quite independently of my own prediction, the number of debates conducted in a way that brings this quote to mind has been steadily increasing – just as was the case following the access ban imposed on T24.
The decision to block access to T24’s website and X account – and, moreover, the fact that this was justified by the claim that “LGBTQ+ propaganda” was being disseminated, citing 118 opinion pieces published on the platform’s website – is a tragicomic situation. So much so that even pro-government figures, such as Nagehan Alçı, criticized the decision.
Apart from Alçı, there was, as one would expect, a significant outcry against this censorship. In particular, members of the press, professional organizations, civil society organizations and public figures have spoken out loudly against this unlawful act and issued messages of solidarity. This is due not only to the absurdity of the decision but also to the fact that T24 is one of Turkey’s most visible and widely followed online news sites, regardless of its political or ideological stance.
However, as access blocking orders were also issued during the same period not only against T24 but also against the social media accounts of thousands of users—including numerous journalists—the issue remains a hot topic, even if only in its dimension relating to the press.
Indeed, journalists and professional organizations in particular have begun to view these access blocks as a genuine and serious threat and are resolutely seeking solutions to counter them. To be honest, I have never before seen the media address this issue with such determination and in such numbers, nor have I seen it given such serious consideration. However, I must say with regret that this reaction and the search for solutions have come far, far too late; in my view, it is already too late. There are two reasons why I think this.
This is not the first time it has been applied to the press
Let me start with the first: Access restrictions are not being applied to the press – particularly the independent press – for the first time.
For example, the Mezopotamya Agency, one of the leading voices of the Kurdish press which also publishes in Turkish, has been regularly blocked for years.
In the first nine months of this year alone, access to a total of 24 different accounts belonging to the agency across various social media platforms was blocked. Similarly, JinNews, another key player in the Kurdish press, had 13 different X and TikTok accounts blocked during the same period.
Özgürüz 5; Azadiya Welat, Etkin News Agency, Evrensel newspaper (along with the supplements Ekmek ve Gül and Genç Hayat), Köz Newspaper, Kızıl Bayrak, Jiyan News and Yeni Yaşam newspaper 3; Hatay Onuncu Köy Newspaper 2 – these were among the news platforms whose social media accounts were blocked multiple times or subject to blocking orders this year.
The picture is no different when it comes to LGBTI+ journalism.
Kaos GL’s nine different accounts across various social media platforms and two domain names were blocked between 12 and 16 September alone. Another platform covering LGBTI+ news, Velvele, also had five social media accounts and one domain name blocked during the same period. Moreover, two of these social media accounts had already been blocked under a decision issued in June.
In addition to these, Voice of America Kurdi, Cumhuriyet newspaper, Gazete Perperik, Sendika.Org, Sol Haber and The Amargi were also among the more than 15 publishers whose social media accounts were subject to blocking orders this year.
If we look at domain name blocks and go back a little further, the picture becomes even more striking. Sendika.Org had 63 domain names blocked between 2015 and 2020, JinNews had 55 blocked since 2015, whilst Etkin News Agency (ETHA) had 21 different domain names blocked in 2022 alone.
However, none of these publishers were discussed to the same extent as T24 is today during the periods when they were blocked. Nor did a response emerge that was as widespread, organized and determined to find a solution as the one we are seeing today in the face of the censorship they endured.
Please do not think that I am complaining about the blocking of T24 being on the agenda. On the contrary, I am pleased that this issue is on the agenda and continues to be so, both because it has created a climate of debate that has prompted me to write this article, and because it has, for the first time, fostered such a resolute media environment in the face of censorship.
There are two things I take issue with here:
Firstly, of course, the blocking of access to T24.
Secondly, the fact that journalists and professional organizations remained so passive in the face of previous access-blocking decisions—which were also used as a tool of pressure against press and freedom of expression at the time—that the authorities felt comfortable issuing the decision to block T24.
For journalists and professional organizations have, up to now, largely confined themselves to the same two responses:
Moreover, even this apparent lack of response—which might be mistaken for a reaction—has not been displayed with the same intensity as it has been in the face of the blocking of the publishers I mentioned earlier.
I believe this lack of reaction has also played a part in T24 being blocked so easily.
This is because the pattern I have consistently observed in my research and analysis of press and freedom of expression in the digital sphere has been almost always the same: every new decision to block access to the press tests the limits of the reaction that followed the previous decision a little further. When no response strong enough to force decision-makers to back down emerges, the scope of the next decision widens and the intensity of the crackdown increases.
In other words, today’s decision regarding T24 did not materialize overnight. There were many thresholds to be crossed before it came to this, and the vast majority of those thresholds were crossed without encountering sufficient resistance.
It is not just the independent press that is being blockedAnother factor in the ease with which these thresholds were crossed – and the second reason why I believe it is “too late to seek a solution to censorship – is the press’ assumption that access restrictions are applied solely to themselves, along with leading opposition civil society organizations, activists, politicians, artists, writers and the like. Yet this is not true.
For example, according to my data, out of the more than 2,000 social media accounts blocked in 2025, only around 80 belonged to journalists. Even when we add the other groups I mentioned above, this figure does not even reach 200.
Today, as of September, the majority of accounts blocked from access still belong to ordinary citizens. In fact, these include voters of the Justice and Development Party (AKP).
For example, although she later deleted it, even the social media influencer N. Çaydan – known for her proximity to the government – reacted to this situation with the following post on her X account:
“I value freedom of expression; if I did not, I would not have got involved in this precarious situation. Nor did I study journalism to remain silent in the face of all forms of censorship. To those friends who could not care less about these events, let me just say this: it could happen to you tomorrow. [...] Although most of the accounts subject to access restrictions have used harsh words against me personally, I do not want those people to be silenced for the rest of their lives. The freedom to receive information and to criticize is their right too.”
You can read a few other examples in this article of Medyascope.
Consequently, the fact that the issue is generally addressed not in terms of citizens but solely through the prism of the press and prominent opposition figures obscures the true scale of the censorship.
To what extent do the proposed solutions actually offer a solution?This incomplete understanding is directly reflected in the search for solutions.
Indeed, the most prominent solution on social media so far has been to open a new account to replace the blocked one. However, whilst this method is a well-intentioned effort, it is neither a solution nor does it prevent the normalization of access restrictions. Indeed, as of September, new accounts opened to replace previously blocked ones account for a significant proportion of the blocked accounts.
Another proposed solution is to use a VPN. However, blocking VPN services is no great difficulty for the authorities. Moreover, since December 2023, the websites of 16 VPN services have been blocked from access in Turkey as is the case.Although the apps remain available for download from mobile app stores, this block sends a significant message to those who opt for VPNs to circumvent the access restrictions. Consequently, just like creating a new account, opting for VPN services offers only a temporary space of freedom.
Moving to a different social media platform, such as Bluesky, is another suggested solution; however, it is not a platform that is immune to access restrictions or capable of resisting them. In February and March 2025, a major exodus from X to Bluesky began in Turkey, but this was short-lived. By April of the same year, access blocking orders had been issued against Bluesky accounts, and the platform implemented them immediately. Consequently, access to 59 Bluesky accounts was blocked, and everyone returned to X.
As I mentioned at the start of this article, independent media outlets and civil society organizations have, for the first time, begun to treat the access block – which has been in place since September and is still ongoing – as a threat of this magnitude. Consequently, they are adopting an extremely resolute stance in their search for a solution. In this context, two proposals stand out:
The first proposal, circulating on social media, is to set up a website and republish the news articles that have been blocked there. I do not regard this as a valid solution either. No initiative or organization we undertake within the digital sphere to counter the rights violations we face in the form of access restrictions is a solution. This is because the internet is entirely under the control of the authorities imposing these restrictions, and consequently, blocking the relevant website will be their first course of action.
Moreover, neither online media nor printed newspapers are read widely enough. Only a very limited audience reads the news online on a regular basis. Based on my experience, I should also point out that the vast majority of news items subject to access restrictions do not make the headlines when they are first published, but rather when the access restriction is imposed. Furthermore, the problem here is not regaining access to the news, but the fact that a decision to restrict access to it has already been made.
Above all, in recent times, it is not the news items themselves that have been blocked, but primarily the social media accounts on which those news items were shared.
The second proposal put forward on social media is to establish a platform comprising journalists, national and international press organizations, civil society organizations working in various fields, and legal professionals. The aim of this platform is to issue a joint press statement involving these groups. This is a proposal with which I partly agree.
The part I agree with is that it proposes taking the search for a solution beyond the virtual world and digital media. Because we are, first and foremost, citizens and human beings with rights, rather than mere “social media users.” Consequently, voicing this attack on our rights through a press statement held in the city center should be our first course of action.
The part I do not agree with begins here: it is proposed that this press conference should, for the time being, be attended only by journalists, national and international press organizations, civil society organizations working in various fields, and legal professionals.
However, this excludes ordinary citizens whose social media accounts have been blocked from the circle. Yet, as I mentioned earlier, they make up the majority of those affected by the access block. Consequently, this approach will neither be inclusive nor will it accurately reflect the scale of the censorship and the public outcry it has caused. However, this would not surprise me, because the issue is not that they cannot see a solution, but that they cannot see the problem itself
